Lady Scouts embroiled in ‘extremely damaging’ authorized conflict with Boy Scouts

The Lady Scouts are in a “extremely damaging” recruitment conflict with the Boy Scouts after the latter opened its core companies to women, resulting in market confusion and a few women unwittingly becoming a member of the Boy Scouts, attorneys for the century-old Lady Scouts group declare in papers filed in a federal court docket.

The competitors, extra conjecture than actuality two years in the past, has intensified because the Boy Scouts of America group — which insists recruits pledge to be “reliable, loyal, useful, pleasant, courteous and type” — has unfairly recruited women recently, in response to claims in authorized briefs filed on behalf of the Lady Scouts of the US of America.

The attorneys filed papers in Manhattan federal court docket Thursday to repel an effort by the Boy Scouts to toss out earlier than trial a trademark infringement lawsuit the Lady Scouts filed in 2018.

Final month, attorneys for the Boy Scouts requested a decide to reject claims that the Boy Scouts can not use “scouts” and “scouting” in its recruitment of ladies with out infringing emblems.

It known as the lawsuit “completely meritless.”

Messages in search of touch upon the newest submitting by Lady Scouts had been despatched Saturday to attorneys for the Boy Scouts.

In its submitting, the Lady Scouts mentioned the Boy Scouts’ advertising of expanded companies for women was “extraordinary and extremely damaging to Lady Scouts” and had set off an “explosion of confusion.”

“Because of Boy Scouts’ infringement, mother and father have mistakenly enrolled their daughters in Boy Scouts pondering it was Lady Scouts,” the attorneys mentioned, including that this by no means occurred earlier than 2018.

The Ladies Scouts mentioned they’ll show there are “rampant situations of confusion and mistaken situations of affiliation between Boy Scouts and Lady Scouts” after the Boy Scouts focused women and their mother and father with advertising and recruiting communications in methods it by no means has earlier than.

“The events’ applications, which have many similarities, at the moment are instantly aggressive,” the Ladies Scouts maintained.

The group cited proof from a slim subset of paperwork turned over by 19 of 250 native Boy Scout councils, together with proof that registration charges generally had been returned to folks who mistakenly thought they registered women for the Lady Scouts.

It mentioned repeated situations of confusion and interference on the native stage by the Boy Scouts was a tiny fraction of what was occurring nationwide.

Every of dozens of occasions the Lady Scouts complained about unfair advertising, the Boy Scouts responded by blaming people, church buildings or others for what they mentioned was an remoted incident, the attorneys mentioned.

“In line with Boy Scouts, blame for the rampant market confusion lies at everybody’s toes however its personal,” they wrote.

Each the Lady Scouts and Boy Scouts, like different main youth organizations, have seen declines in membership in recent times as competitors grew pre-pandemic from sports activities leagues and busy household schedules.

In spring 2018, the Boy Scouts program for 11- to 17-year-olds introduced it might change its title to Scouts BSA in early 2019. The mother or father group, the Boy Scouts of America, and the Cub Scouts, a program serving kids from kindergarten by fifth grade, saved their names.

The group began admitting women into the Cub Scouts in August 2018, and Scouts BSA started accepting women in February, 2019, attorneys mentioned.

Afterward, Boy Scouts councils and volunteers started utilizing Lady Scouts’ mental property to recruit women, using focused promoting using phrases reminiscent of “Scout, Scouts, Scouting, Scout Me In and Scouts BSA,” the attorneys wrote.

“Boy Scouts knew full nicely in 2017, simply because it had within the Thirties and Nineteen Seventies, that SCOUT, SCOUTS and SCOUTING, when utilized in reference to women’ companies, may solely create associations with Lady Scouts until different distinguishing content material referencing Boy Scouts of America appeared in promoting and promotional supplies,” they mentioned. “Nevertheless it did so anyway, and the one believable inference is that its motive was to free journey off of Lady Scouts ‘impeccable’ fame and enhance its place in a ‘new market — Ladies in Scouting.’”

The attorneys mentioned Boy Scouts councils in Illinois acknowledging improperly utilizing the Lady Scouts’ slogan in Cub Scout recruiting supplies and footage of Lady Scouts to advertise a Boy Scouts “Scouts Signal-Up Night time!”

They mentioned a western Massachusetts Boy Scouts council posted a recruiting flyer on Fb together with {a photograph} of a lady depicted in her Lady Scouts Brownie uniform.

In the meantime, Ohio Boy Scouts used the Lady Scouts trademark to attempt to get a neighborhood newspaper to jot down an article, suggesting a storyline entitled “Boy and Lady Scouts On the lookout for Members” despite the fact that the recruitment concerned solely the Boy Scouts, the attorneys mentioned.

In Seattle, a Boy Scouts council used the Lady Scouts trademark in social media recruiting supplies, the attorneys mentioned.

They mentioned confusion has skyrocketed amongst kids, mother and father, colleges and spiritual organizations and so they cited examples in different states, together with Florida, Minnesota, Arkansas, Michigan, North Carolina and Hawaii.

Extra must-read tales from Fortune:

Leave a Reply

Back to top button