Sabinella Ayazbayeva has had a extra eventful life than most younger ladies from Kazakhstan. Born in 1990, she married at 19. She moved to Syria along with her husband and kids in 2014 and joined Islamic State. An airstrike made her a widow in 2017. She and her 5 children finally discovered themselves in al-Hol, a camp for households of ISIS fighters. After greater than a yr of uncertainty within the Syrian desert, they returned to Kazakhstan. She was 29.
“I need my youngsters to neglect about what occurred,” she instructed me by way of a translator on Zoom. “My life goes again to regular.” For the 62,000 folks languishing in al-Hol, life stays removed from regular. Most are Iraqi or Syrian, however about 9,000 got here from different international locations.
The Syrian Democratic Forces run the 736-acre camp with restricted assets. Brutal climate and squalid situations can kill. And a few guards implement ISIS’ interpretation of Islam: Dozens at this “mini-caliphate” have been murdered this yr—with a minimum of 10 beheaded.
The Trump administration oversaw the repatriation of greater than two dozen Americans. Some had been fighters, however Washington additionally facilitated the return of wives and kids. This was America at its finest: providing the kids of terrorists a shot at a traditional life whereas giving even essentially the most repulsive residents their day in court docket.
However the U.S. has struggled to influence allies to observe go well with. 1000’s of European Union residents joined ISIS. Many survivors are caught in al-Hol, rejected by their dwelling international locations. After years of lecturing Individuals about Guantanamo Bay, European leaders now look away as EU residents are caught in a Syrian Gitmo—albeit with out the Caribbean jail’s facilities. The Biden administration can be urgent Europe. Its success has been restricted.
“The ladies wished to go together with us, however Kazakhstan couldn’t take the nationals of different international locations,” Ms. Ayazbayeva says. “These ladies had been jealous.” Many within the camps have escaped. Some have returned to European international locations like Belgium and the Netherlands, however nobody can know precisely what number of. Repatriation a minimum of permits governments to maintain observe.
“Kazakhstan made a really daring transfer by being the primary nation to repatriate massive numbers of its nationals,”
a Trump State Division official who labored on the difficulty, mentioned in an interview. “They weren’t dipping their toe within the water. They went all in.” The Kazakh authorities repatriated 607 residents by way of a program referred to as Operation Zhusan. Most had been ladies (157) and kids (413). Thirty-seven grownup male fighters confronted prosecution upon arrival. One other 32 ladies and 89 youngsters returned themselves.
The Kazakh authorities sends ladies and kids to rehabilitation facilities, the place they endure an extended course of to assist them reintegrate into society. Some return fully jaded, whereas others stay dedicated to ISIS: One lady tried to smuggle the group’s propaganda into Kazakhstan in a baby’s toy.
“We try to convey them again to regular,” then-Deputy International Minister
instructed me earlier this yr. “We wish to see them as atypical folks.” This created controversy domestically, however the authorities held agency.
“The U.S. devoted a variety of effort to serving to the Kazakhs design, and construct, after which implement their rehabilitation applications,” mentioned Ambassador Nathan Gross sales, State Division counterterrorism coordinator beneath President Trump. The international locations labored collectively to “construct applications based mostly on the state-of-the-art information from fields like childhood trauma, from instructional specialists, from non secular authorities.”
Bibigul Assylova, vice minister of schooling and science, mentioned it might be exhausting to ascertain a rapport at first. When some youngsters painted, “most of their photos had been about bombing.” However youngsters “rehabilitate a lot quicker,” and Ms. Assylova estimates greater than half of the repatriated youngsters attending college have develop into A college students.
Mr. Gross sales famous that “to this point, the indications are good,” however warned that the coverage received’t succeed with out sustained consideration. Kazakh officers admit some contributors of the rehabilitation program retain radical views. Mr. Ashikbayev mentioned legislation enforcement might help mitigate danger however “we won’t be in all probability at 100% success and we will certainly be having issues.”
Landlocked Kazakhstan, a former Soviet republic, is much from a human-rights paradise. Freedom Home calls it a “consolidated authoritarian regime,” however on ISIS households Kazakhstan has taken a extra humanitarian method than many European democracies.
The nation’s leaders see a much bigger precept at stake. “It has to do with identification. Kazakhstan is a really younger nation. We gained independence solely 30 years in the past,” Mr. Ashikbayev mentioned. “This repatriation effort clearly demonstrates that we’re not solely a peaceable society however we might additionally prefer to protect our identification as a state.”
Mr. O’Neal is a European-based editorial web page author for the Journal.
Copyright ©2020 Dow Jones & Firm, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 87990cbe856818d5eddac44c7b1cdeb8